Archive for the ‘critique’ Category

Revisiting Robbers Cave: The easy spontaneity of intergroup conflict | Literally Psyched, Scientific American Blog Network

Revisiting Robbers Cave: The easy spontaneity of intergroup conflict | Literally Psyched, Scientific American Blog Network.

I came across the study many, many years ago, and reading it anew is refreshing. It’s actually quite important for anyone involved in building collaborative communities to read and understand.

Professional Archiving Solution | OPENARCHIVE

Professional Archiving Solution | OPENARCHIVE.

 

Big Data is here to stay (though it’s not quite proven itself as useful as imagined) and it analyzing it–making sense of the data that are captured–is only part of the picture. It has to be stored, archived. How this is done is as much of interest as how the data are used (and by whom). And as with other things that are actually socially important, or can be, I’m in favour of commons-based solutions, open standards, open source. The interesting thing about open source and archiving, however, is related in OpenArchive’s Product Page (emphasis mine):

Features and functions of OPENARCHIVE

OPENARCHIVE offers all the functions of ARCHIVEMANAGER, except for two features. There can be no audit compliance according to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (GDPdu and GoBS in Germany) because publishing the  source code would be detrimental to those legal requirements. And, at the present time, no independent software manufacturers (ISV) have yet certified their applications for OPENARCHIVE.

That legal requirement is interesting. And it also flies in the face of my no doubt miserable understanding of the issues. For the security of the data are not compromised by making the code ensuring their security open. Openness relates to the elements making up the machine and even how it is supposed to function, not to the output. It’s worth investigating, I’d think, how Sarbanes-Oxley really intersects with open source issues here.

 

 

Greek Government and Public at Odds Over New Cuts – NYTimes.com

I get depressed that the futures of millions rests, it seems, on the sentiments of single individuals–Draghi, Merkel, Bernanke–and not on process. It’s not that I fetishize bureaucracy (which is all about process and procedure and not about people) but that I should think the whole point of having the science of economics and the vehicles which deliver the knowledge gained by that science’s application should be so, well, ignored, all in favour of sentiment. It’s not in favour of the irrational, per se, but in favour of personal and idiosyncratic desires. (The irrational means, if we do want to use it, relying on local and personal desires, however logical, when the expectation is for something more general. It only makes sense to me, one could say, but it really does make sense. I guess this means that I tend to believe, I really do, that all persons, barring absolute madness, amenable to rational discourse: they can be persuaded away from their current thinking by the strength of facts well presented.)

Greek Government and Public at Odds Over New Cuts – NYTimes.com.

Daring Fireball: Markdown Basics

Daring Fireball: Markdown Basics.

 

Markdown is very useful and this guide is worth the read—though, absurdly, Markdown is so simple that a guide really is not needed. But still. Read it and use Markdown.

LeftyBlogs.com: Taking Back America… in all fifty states. – LeftyBlogs.com

LeftyBlogs.com: Taking Back America… in all fifty states. – LeftyBlogs.com.

Interesting. Would be worth looking to see if there is something like this for other categories, including open source–theory, praxis, policy.

I am fairly engaged in open standards activity as well as community, so this post struck me as relevant and interesting.

brendanscott's avatarBrendan Scott's Weblog

Open Source Law Releases Report On Open Standards

Update: UK Open source principles released

I have been doing a bit of work for a variety of people recently relating to standards and standards setting.  In early May I saw that the UK open standards consultation process had been extended because of a potential conflict of interest by one of the facilitators.  Linux Australia commissioned a report from me about Open Standards.  That report (link below) was completed last week and, I understand,  Linux Australia has used it as a basis for a submission to the UK Open Standards Consultation process.  The report covers a variety of issues relating to open standards.  Some of the issues it covers are:

  • the difference between open formats and open standards.  I think if government focusses on open “standards”, then that’s a big problem.  In practice it would resolve to “open standards or anything…

View original post 222 more words

After Violence, India Cracks Down on Web and Texts – NYTimes.com

After Violence, India Cracks Down on Web and Texts – NYTimes.com.

More needs to be written on this–it’s a tremendously interesting problematic, and though India is probably the most visible and arguably most important exemplar, it’s not the only. “This” is not just about the existence of new social media but its use; and the devices that are used. And the failure to understand, let alone engage in it as a politician…. well, look to the rise of newspapers or even samizdat press.

:: GRTC – Mission 2015 – 2015 and Beyond ::

:: GRTC – Mission 2015 – 2015 and Beyond ::.

Greater Richmond’s transit plans are a joke–I mean they make one laugh at the planners who have done this work, and less directly, at the fool taxpayers who probably righteously feel that any of their precious money that has been ripped from their cold hands under the pretence of legal taxation should never to go actual social services that actually knit together the community of which they only want to be the elite members, certainly not–never–the body that makes up the politic. Welcome to libertarian America, which daily proves the Maggie assertion that there is no society. Thus, to travel by car (perish bikes) from one shopping centre to another, I learned, means to go on decent roads (provided it’s not snowing) that are by and large not lit (social waste of money, esp. as cars have headlights, don’t they?) and where the entire set up lives out Neal Stephenson’s brilliantly acidic satire of the US republic in Snow Crash: no communities but franchise ‘burb claves. The logical evolution of the identity community in a libertarian environment, where the first thing to go is the commons that actually bring us together so that we may actually do something about the problems that beset us all.

 

La Pintora Lita

I’m drafting an article for Wikipedia on La Pintora LIta (“Lita”), who gained fame in Mexico in the middle of last century for her remarkably beautiful portraits of bullfighters, businessmen & their wives, and politicians. She also made pencil portraits of her children, especially of her daughter, Mimi, and these were filled with astonishing love.

Lita was my grandmother. One day, not long after she had broken her shoulder in on the way home from Ralph’s in Los Angeles (and not far from where OJ Simpson would end up in infamy) she asked us if we’d rather she be our grandmother or continue her life as an artist. We, my brother and I, were 9 and 10, but we spoke immediately and univocally that we’d rather she stay the famous Lita. (Famous: a letter sent to her some time in the late 50s go to her even though it only had, “La Pintora Lita” as the address.)

But she didn’t really return to her art and she instead descended slowly into retirement. Yet, surrounded by some of the best of her work, and by all the loving portraits of her children and grandchildren, surrounded as we always had been, and by the consciousness of her fame, I almost missed that descent until much later. 

She died 20 years ago; her birthday, on 6 September, remains something that my brother and I remember. (My mother, Mimi, would call me on its anniversary, but no longer: she passed away last August, after a swift decline in Guadalajara, which she never really liked as much as her beloved DF.) Her wake–there was no proper funeral and no one expected it, as we are all atheists, but there was a wake, and that was amazingly and brutally cathartic–made me want to gather the leaves of her work and effects before they were all scattered. As a scholar who studied a lot of dead people’s work, I was and remain familiar with what happens to people after death. Unless they are lucky, their effects and memories are caught and carried on by many, diffused and refracted across personalities and distances: puzzle jigsawed. This is our fate.

But I thought that Lita’s would be different; after all, she was famous. But not, I learned soon, famous enough, and not famous enough to overcome the resistance of the living to memorialize her–a process that is often painful because, at the least, it can force into evidence the memory of things long hidden. And no one but those having nothing to lose like that process of discovery. Certainly not some members of my family. 

And even in the absence of the threat of harm it still takes a tremendous amount of energy to uncover and then put together someone else’s past. It’s one thing to compile a memory book of photographs, it’s quite another to go to the many who own the portrait and ask for the permission to record it for posterity. That’s especially the case when the visit to the owner of the portrait puts the seeker in the odd position of a frame whose identity betrays the seeker. I mean, of course, that if my mother had asked for permission to record–photograph or whatever–the portrait owned by the family of the deceased bullfighter or businessperson, she would have to confront the thorny fact that people knew her, if at all, as Lita’s daughter, not as someone who strove, all her life–and with mixed success–to be her own woman. The acquisition of the past is never without its consequences, and these can be very personal indeed, especially if one’s own present is never as secure as one would wish.

I Googled Lita today. I’ve done that before, but the reality given by Google changes as people use it. But nothing pertaining to Lita–Dolores Laura Balch (married name was “Potts”, but she never ever used that, at least as long as I knew her)–came up. Her most famous work nowadays  (and its still on display, I believe, in Mexico)–is a black and white pencil portrait of a young Indian girl with her baby brother; or perhaps a young mother with her baby. It’s called El Mexicanito, and upon Lita’s death was the subject of some family dispute. But that’s boring.

What I’d like to see if it’s feasible to gather representations of her work so that I can write my Wikipedia article. Her life is interesting enough to merit such an article, and it also provides a lens on mid-20th century Mexican culture. And US postwar culture, particularly as it would relate to women.

That last part is of some interest. Lita was abandoned by her husband of 17 years right after the War, sent to Mexico to stay with her father on the promise that her husband with join her shortly. He didn’t; in fact, it turns out he had another wife, in Los Angeles, and turned to her. But LIta and her two children (a third was kept with the father and would later join the Navy at a preposterously young age) were left abandoned with a family still reeling from her father’s Lupus and the losses of the Great Depression, in Hermosillo, Mexico.

She stayed there a very short time and, for reasons I don’t quite understand, to this day, left for DF with my mother and uncle (8 and 3) and fairly quickly found work as a commercial artist. She had never done that before. But the great Cantinflas recognized her talent (which I think a friend had exposed him to; Cantinflas had a patron’s generosity) got her a job as the artist in a fairly large company. Her talent was such and her brains, too, that she very quickly was able to establish her identity as, effectively *the* artist for the Mexican bullfighting ring.

Think about that. Here is he, a woman of a certain age with three children, whose Spanish was thick with American vowels, but who had decent family from both sides of the border, creating portraits of bullfighters at a time when Hemingway’s romance of the crowd was strong and masculine–and perhaps that’s why she, an American woman achingly pure and proper, could enter into the ring and do so well and be so loved.

U.S. tourist’s desire for gun in Calgary park sparks Twitter storm – thestar.com

U.S. tourist’s desire for gun in Calgary park sparks Twitter storm – thestar.com.

Commentary would wreck the absurdity of the situation. And absurdity here means the same kind that Ionescu used to describe the rationale for exponentially excessive violence, suspicion, xenophobia.